I once had a player that wanted a Decanter of Endless Water just to waterboard people 😳
8 points
Yes. It’s specifies there’s ten minutes of air. But the bag woodt need to be closed to not have air exchange.
4 points
You’re right, and the rules (both 3.5 and 5) even explicitly state that after ten minutes the creature suffocates. I was hoping that the RAW was simply “holds enough air for a Medium creature to breathe for ten minutes” which I could try to argue was merely a statement about the inner volume of the bag.
