cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ml/post/19046336
Oh so smug, and yet still “European social liberals” are constantly on the brink of having their own outbreak of fascism.
Our implementation isn’t flawless, either. Things generally started to go downhill in the 90s when the direct ideological competitor in the form of the soviet block vanished. The rise of New Labour, a flurry of completely mismanaged privatisations, etc. The system overall is annoyingly sluggish but there very much is consciousness that that fascist stuff and that we now have a precariat are connected. Acting on that consciousness is harder.
In any case that’s not a fault of the theory itself: Things fall apart pretty precisely in those spots where it’s being ignored.
Oh yes, it’s simply because the US is the US, and has nothing to do with the fact that we’ve had neoliberal politicians for approximately 50 years.
I’m sorry yes you having that kind of politics in the past is exactly why the US is how the US is. Like, time and determinism exist. Longer than that, actually: While things went downhill in the US approximately with Nixon, you on top of that started that slide from a lower starting point. Random example: You never had a right to housing. Not just “well if Democrats are in power we might be lucky and get a social housing project” but “Can’t make rent? Can’t find an apartment? Push come to shove the state will have to pay for a hotel room and if they don’t courts will hold the mayor in contempt”. Those kinds of difference goes all the way back to rugged individualism and whatnot. Or, less detailed but not less accurate: Because the US is the US.
Also, comments like “rule of law doesn’t work in Somalia because it’s Somalia” show me you have exactly nothing to add to any conversation about geopolitics and borders on racism.
The fuck would race have to do with anything you really are American. Xeer does not have enforcement mechanisms that could deal with the current political and security situation, that’s all that I’m saying. Somalian judges can make the justest judgements the earth has ever seen, ultimately Mao is still right about gun barrels.
Those kinds of difference goes all the way back to rugged individualism and whatnot. Or, less detailed but not less accurate: Because the US is the US.
“I heard a phrase once about Americans, so that must be why they’re sliding towards fascism. It definitely can’t be for the same reasons people have pointed to for a hundred years.”
The fuck would race have to do with anything you really are American.
Right, right, it’s not that Somalia is Somalia, it’s something in their “culture”? Right?
It definitely can’t be for the same reasons people have pointed to for a hundred years.”
What are the reasons those pointed-at reasons persist? Why does is that persistence more pronounced is some places, but not others? Can there be a symptom without underlying causes?
How come e.g. the death penalty is still accepted as a topic of polite conversation in America? I maybe shouldn’t have led with rugged individualism, e.g. Australians have a similar streak in that regard, the real core of the issue is that the Enlightenment never truly arrived in the US. Jingoism, understood as the general notion of “we’re already the best it’s impossible for us to get better by learning from others” also plays a large role, I guess it’s half your isolationist streak, and half strategy by the powers that be to avoid questioning of the status quo. There’s definitely policy in place to reinforce it through the education system – from limited and navel-gazing curriculum to the pledge of allegiance which btw is fascist AF.
Right, right, it’s not that Somalia is Somalia, it’s something in their “culture”? Right?
I specifically mentioned Xeer, no need on your part to speculate, or pretend I wasn’t being clear.
What are the reasons those pointed-at reasons persist? Why does is that persistence more pronounced is some places, but not others? Can there be a symptom without underlying causes?
Read theory if you’re actually curious and not just posting to post. Personally, I’ve come to think of inequality as being at the center of it all.
But the reason is certainly not “because <<country>> is <<country>>”.
