You are viewing a single thread.
View all comments
67 points

I can’t remember for the life of me where I read it, but I remember reading a kinda sci-fi/fantasyish novel in my teens that had universal ai controlled cars, and the main character asked how they didn’t get into accidents sometimes and the other characters were like “are you stupid? It’s one centralised ai controlling them all” and that stuck with me as an obvious requirement for driverless cars.

Anyway I don’t think any current driverless car creators read that book.

permalink
report
reply
69 points

driverless cars coordinated and controlled from a single central source to ensure smooth operation and maximum efficiency

each car individually controlled by competing ai each trying to reduce their transit time at the expense of the other AI operated cars

permalink
report
parent
reply
41 points

I remember during the initial hype for driverless cars there was a plan for cars to have ad hoc/ mesh networks with each other so they could perfectly optimize traffic and weave lane changes and left turns in between much smaller gaps than humans can. Somehow it seems just as far away as when it was first proposed.

permalink
report
parent
reply
30 points

Somehow it seems just as far away as when it was first proposed.

Probably further away than when it was first proposed tbh

permalink
report
parent
reply
25 points

Replace all car roads with trolley tracks, a huge sprawling network of tracks, with streetcars all operated with AI planning. Hell let people buy their own personal trolleys if they want, just don’t let them disconnect from the central planning system, get out where you want and the trolley will head to a tracked storage facility to await your next pickup, out of the way of incoming trolleys all perfectly maneuvering around the city

Life purely on the rails

permalink
report
parent
reply
40 points

The invisible crankshaft of the free market.

permalink
report
parent
reply
9 points

Game theory but for AI cars

permalink
report
parent
reply
54 points

One central AI controlling all of them is just the first step into reinventing trains, again.

permalink
report
parent
reply
51 points

Trains are to transit evolution as crabs are to biological evolution. If you actually try to improve efficiency in any transit system you’ll inevitably reinvent trains.

It’s still funny that these car-brained tech bros can’t go beyond individual cars controlled independently even when faced with both the obvious downsides and inefficiencies as well as clear ways to improve car based transit.

permalink
report
parent
reply
29 points
*

as crabs are to biological evolution

Barely related, but I want to point out that carcinization only happens to hard shelled creatures, possibly only aquatic ones. Different groups of animals have a few different ideal forms.

For predatory mammals, the ideal form is ferret. Become long.

permalink
report
parent
reply
4 points
*

Reading this comment chain on a high speed train really enriches the experience

permalink
report
parent
reply
16 points
*

one centralised ai controlling them all"

Too close to commie trains, their minds just can’t conceive

permalink
report
parent
reply

If by “ai” you mean pathfinding and routing algorithms, that makes total sense. If by “ai” you mean the actual driving part and crash avoidance, ping will start killing pedestrians.

permalink
report
parent
reply
6 points

Some sort if hybrid system would be great. Knowing that there are no cars on the intersection you plan to cross would save a lot of time with slowing down to check. Equally, having on board systems to slam on the anchors because someone is in the road or whatever would be a requirement.

permalink
report
parent
reply

Waymos as it stands are very good at not crashing. Humans are very bad drivers and frequently hit things, the waymos have been good at not doing that with whatever system they are using now. Obviously there are a few kinks, but it’s not enough to discard the technology. A self driving car is better than a human driven one, but it’s still a car.

permalink
report
parent
reply
9 points

In Too Like the Lightning by Ada Palmer there are people artificially enhanced into supercomputers that control the world’s network of flying cars.

permalink
report
parent
reply
8 points
*
Deleted by creator
permalink
report
parent
reply