Kinda like the idea of incrementally longer bans for each offense.
That’s MUCH BETTER actually. 3 warnings, then 1 day, and increase the amount of days for each offense.
I used to moderate a forum some years ago, with incremental bans. It was warning, warning, 1d, 3d, 7d, 15d, 1m, permaban.
It does not work well. For good users the system is irrelevant, they drop the behaviour after a single warning; shitty users keep the same behaviour even after the short bans are over, and then evade the larger bans, so you’re basically taking multiple mod actions for what could be handled with a single one.
Eventually the forum shifted into a “three warnings and you’re permabanned” system, but by then I wasn’t a mod there any more so I don’t know how well it worked.
A 5y ban is a permaban under another name. By then the user already disengaged the community, or circumvented the ban.
