2 points
Or, perhaps go the PF2e route and allow the player to tack on a weapon maneuver of choice if their attack roll exceeds the target AC by a certain amount (5?)
1 point
Too much math for 5e’s design philosophy, and with bounded accuracy it would need a crit on the strongest enemies anyway.
The actual implementation of that system could take a number of forms:
- PB/LR for every class that is proficient with the given weapon. (The most basic implementation, but also screws over pure martials in favor of half casters.)
- PB/LR for every class that is proficient, but fighters regain PB/2 uses when they use Second Wind.
- PB/LR for every class that is proficient, PB/SR for fighters, monks, and barbarians.
- PB/LR for every class that is proficient, fighters regain all uses when rolling initiative.
- Etc…
