24 points
It’s the same metaphor though. Helping a group of people doesn’t hurt a different group. Did they make a decision based on whether they expected to get help: yes. Does providing that help against that expectation hurt them: no.
It’s an especially good metaphor because nobody is even talking about taxing tradies to fund the relief.
1 point
*
10 points
*
Can’t they do both? Do they still need to kill all the people on the tracks? That part of the argument isn’t coherent.
