I like how you completely ignored the premise of my criticism of only reading the exact text, and just referenced the exact text again. Incredibly naive view of government, but I can see I won’t be able to change that today.
I understand your criticism but I don’t think it’s informed or accurate. I can see how you would believe it if you only got your news through tabloid headlines. The bill in no way outlaws drag queens or drag shows. If they believed that all drag shows were sexual why did they make specific considerations that allow for drag shows to still exist?
it’s hardly a stretch to argue it will be expanded to include trans people. I argue it is a stretch. this bill is about sexual performances in front of children. It does not apply to anything else
I don’t think you do understand my criticism because you just again did the thing I’m criticizing. I’m saying the text of the law is not the whole picture because the real world application also matters and doesn’t always perfectly reflect the literal text, and you just keep referring me back to the text of the law. I’m doing my damnedest to assume good intent from you but you are making it so hard. I don’t think you’d be this deferential to government in most other situations.
I don’t buy your criticism in this instance. This is what you originally said:
Laws must be viewed wholistically. You cannot simply examine the text as if it somehow came into being on its own and enforces itself as a perfectly neutral rule of nature. It is written and applied by humans. So, you must also look at the framers who wrote it and those who will apply it.
And if we do, we see that they mean all drag shows are sexual. You clearly do agree with this interpretation so I’m not sure why you’re trying to deploy this smokescreen. They intend to use this as a ban on children being “exposed” to drag in any form, and it’s hardly a stretch to argue it will be expanded to include trans people.
This is quite the statement with absolutely 0 to back it up. “Yeah I know it doesnt actually ban dragshows, but it actually just means they’re going to eventually ban all of them and also ban trans people!” is not really a coherent. I think your view on the intent of this bill is poisoned by the main stream media which constantly insists that this is banning drag shows, when in reality it just been gratuitous sexuality when children are around.
