Comment by Cyclohexane@lemmy.ml on History lives in the present

Context (for those who don’t know): Israel and Palestine

Palestine is not a religious entity, and have been in favor of religious coexistence since the very beginning. It is the Zionist state that is exclusive of other religions by design.

All the yelling of “Allahu akbar” while celebrating the death and destruction in Israel, would seem to be in conflict with your statement.

Not all Palestinians are Hamas…

yelling of “Allahu akbar”

Saying “God is great” is problematic?

celebrating the death and destruction in Israel

They are resisting against the Zionist state founded on genocide and exclusivism. I don’t see that violating their will for coexistance.

Saying “God is great” is problematic?

Obviously

When they’re celebrating the killing of civilians at a dance party, or the beheading of babies, it is a problem. Religion is the cancer that keeps that entire region either at war, or the brink of war

You’re gonna have to substantiate that claim. Show me evidence of Palestinians celebrating “killing of civilians at a dance party, or the beheading of babies”. Without evidence, your claim is to be ignored.

By the way, Israel has already admitted that they faked the “beheading of babies” story. Verify your evidence before responding.

Your link shows several quotes from the idf… all of which says “we cannot confirm” not any confirmation of the statement being a lie that i can see. Nor is there any evidence that an official Israeli representative started this story.

Stop lying about “evidence” before responding.

They previously presented as fact. Now they’re saying they can’t confirm it and cannot present any evidence. I don’t believe they have to spell out “we lied” for it to be obvious.

Biden said

No offense, but that’s all the reason not to believe it. “Guys I have proof! I won’t show you but trust me bro, I’ve seen it!”

Saying “God is great” is problematic?

Forgot a “while murdering and beheading innocent civilians” there

So then, why is their official goal to destroy Israel? Thats 100% a religious war

Israel is by its own definition the Zionist state founded on religious exclusivism. An ethnocentric state in a land inhabited by other religions and ethnicities. It should absolutely be taken down.

religious war

Israel is not Judaism.

An ethnocentric state in a land inhabited by other religions and ethnicities.

In land bordering the lands of lther religions and ethnicities.

What exactly justifies the takedown of Israel? That its religion is different or what? Thats none of ghe other countries business.

as I already said above, it is because it is an ethnoreligious state that excludes people of other ethnicities (Arabs, Africans, etc) and other religions (Muslims, Christians, etc). It has engaged in massacre and forced expulsion of those people, so it must be taken down and the genocide must cease.

ethnoreligious state that excludes people of other ethnicities (Arabs, Africans, etc) and other religions (Muslims, Christians, etc)

So what? Thats their business what rules they want to have inside their country. Thats nl reason to attack them.

forced expulsion of those people, so it must be taken down and the genocide must cease.

Forced expulsion is dtill inside their own country. So you take them down with a genocide yourself? Fight fire with fire?

No it is not their business to genocide ethnic and religious minorities lmao. Would you say the same about the Nazis too? was the US justified in genociding native americans also? ridiculous.

Forced expulsion is dtill inside their own country

yes it is. I hope you dont mean that this makes it better. I may be failing to understand this genocide sympathizer logic.

So you take them down with a genocide yourself?

No. The only one committing genocide at the moment and in this conflict is Israel itself.

So what? Thats their business what rules they want to have inside their country.

Come on…

Rules:

Be civil and nice.
Try not to excessively repost, as a rule of thumb, wait at least 2 months to do it if you have to.

History lives in the present(lemmy.zip)

Memes

!memes@lemmy.ml

Rules:

Community stats

Community moderators