Your arguments would only work if you’d argue for breaking up or nationalizing YouTube.

As long as they are a for-profit company you can’t deny them the right to legally earn money the way they see fit, doesn’t matter how big they are or what other revenue streams they have. Forcing them to offer a service for free is nonsense, and attacking them on a technicality that is probably easily circumvented is just a waste of everybody’s time and money imo.

If we really want to do something about this then we have to break their monopoly, same as any other huge company that’s f*cking with consumers.