I think the main thing to get out of this is to just see what beauty your natural ecosystem has to offer
At this point, seeing behavior and responses like this in so many communities of my interests, I feel like even that gentle of an approach is still too much agenda-pushing.
Not that the agenda in question lacks for value, ethics, or good intentions, but at the end of the day, based on the newbies inquiry, itâs still some version of, âYouâre wrong for wanting to explore your interest. You should do what I tell you to do instead.â
In the communities for my interests that I participate in, I try (and sometimes fail, weâre all human), to explicitly steer clear of doing anything to diminish their enthusiasm, curiosity, and desire to learn. Thatâs the little ember that they need to really get going, so for me, the priority is not to put that out.
Especially in a case like this where, sure, maybe a native garden is idealâŚbut the alternative if they get overwhelmed or shut down or forcibly redirected by the community is probably just going to be grass and weeds, or no plants at all.
I think itâs great to offer up the natives as an alternative (while explaining the benefits to both the local ecosystem as well as to the gardener), but I would also say that if youâre going to do that, one should also encourage them to get into their new interest regardless of whether they follow that suggestion or not.
If OP wants to plant tulips, fantastic, and Iâll give you any tips I can on how to do that. I may suggest natives and why theyâre also a great choice, but under no circumstances will I go into negative territory in telling them they shouldnât follow up on their interest, unless of course itâs illegal, dangerous, harmful, etc.
And if op explicitly wants roses and tulips good for them. It should be âhereâs how to start out with those. <Tulip info>. If youâre curious, thereâs some pretty cool native plants that do well, and local pollinators love em. I think youâll enjoy them to. Hit me up if you want to chat about selecting native species, Iâm pretty into thatâ
Exactly! Very well said!
Donât make a new interest a âdonât do what interests you, do what interests meâ thing.
Iâm big into fishing and while people are generally pretty good to newbies, people can get ridiculously preachy over catch and release vs keeping fish, as well as safe and ethical fish handling practices.
Iâm all about educating, but A) you need to do it with positivity and not guilt, B) a lot of times people get super, super anal about itâŚlike⌠weâre all jamming a hook in a fishâs mouth and dragging it out of the waterâŚin that context, laying it on some wet grass to quickly unhook it and get a picture is not the worst part of its day, and C) just because their fish handling may not be perfect doesnât mean itâs cruel eitherâŚnewbies gotta learn, and theyâre going to learn better from gentle suggestion and explanation than coming at them telling them how wrong they are.