Comment by pyrflie@lemm.ee on It's all correct.

No…they killed him because he represented a risk to the standing power structure.

They strung him up next to common criminals to lower his status, to make his whole idea seem insignificant.

No comment on weather he was supernatural.

I don’t think he did any magic tricks with the weather

I think he calmed a storm one time, but I might be thinking of Thor.

Sea of galilea, I think.

Am I praying to the wrong god to make it rain when I hit the casino?

There are even Roman records to the fact.

… kiiiiiiiiinda

It kinda feels like you’re pushing an anti-Semitic narrative here instead of trying to argue the history.

The Jewish people were not some minor cult. The story does go that the Jewish authorities did argue for Jesus to be executed, part of it definitely being because of his “king of the Jews” thing. Judaism as a religion and The Jewish people are not 1 and the same in context, Jesus famously was not anti-Roman and argued his teachings were of the mind.

The Romans were famous for incorporating local government structures and religions as long as you paid and served.

Yes according to the myth the Jewish Authorities ( again, integrated and part of the Roman governing of the area) pushed for him to be executed for claiming to be the king of the Jews (political) which would upset Roman rule.

Again, this is of course assuming you believe the myth that actually isn’t written about or recorded at all until a couple generations later.

There aren’t Roman records of the event until later, after the fact. From people who weren’t there, but heard about it from people who were or heard it from folks who were … etc.

When didi use the word Roman?

There is no contemporary record of Jesus or his crucifixion.

Existing … see previous response.

See response to other commenter.

Yeah and the Romans were always 100% accurate in their historical accounts, right?

Non personal accounts probably. Roman editorialism was mostly personal, for everything else blame Theodosius the Arsonist.

air of ‘i’m special’

risk to the standing power structure

These two ideas are arguably very similar. Claiming religious or political standing is both claiming an air of uniqueness and a threat to the status quo, and to my understanding this guy was doing both. ☺️

The argument made is that the Romans saw no threat. The Romans didn’t give a fuck about the religious part. As far as they were concerned he was no threat.

That’s how the story goes at least, a story rewritten over and over by Romans so why would they make themselves look bad?

I think you’re misunderstanding a bit what I mean.

The Roman people have every reason to change the narrative to make it the others who killed him.

No I think I totally agree and understand exactly what you mean. 🙃🙃

I promise my comment is only saying what it said, face value. No subtext lol :)

Absolutely not. He was claiming to be the King of the Jews. He was literally claiming political power. He wasn’t just saying “hey I’m a super cool religious figure.”

i have amended my statement i guess the way i phrased it made a lot of people upset so i apologize, that was definitely not my intent and still not sure why that happened.

would love to hear your thoughts on my edited statement if you have them :)

It just says “deleted” for me. No worries dude, it’s just an internet argument :P

The argument actually is that he was making a religious argument, his kingdom was of the mind.

There is an effort to make that point: “give to the Roman’s that which is theirs”

A lot of the argument was about the tacit acceptance that the theology of the day dictated how you ought to live and it had been twisted.

The power structure that he was upsetting was that of the ruling Jewish political body because it called their theology into question.

The Roman’s were 100% in charge and didn’t give a fuck he could be the king of the space dolphins as long as they paid their taxes too.

There’s a sort of old Twitter esque, “Everything must be challenged and I’ve been having this argument with other people for 4 days straight” energy here, yeah.

As someone who didn’t use Twitter, I would always get in these weird arguments with my friends that were crazily out of proportion. Then when they would cool down later I would predictably learn they were coming fresh off a Twitter debate where everything everyone says is in bad faith.

It’s kinda fun getting that experience now tho, I feel like I missed out a bit!

need to have a new rule that you don’t get to comment unless you’d be willing to give the other person a hug or at least a firm handshake

hate being shouted down literally because the other person gets a rush of dopamine

No, you just said something that made no sense and got called on it. That’s not toxic, it’s just clear speech.

And then, one Thursday, nearly two thousand years after one man had been nailed to a tree for saying how great it would be to be nice to people for a change, one girl sitting on her own in a small cafe in Rickmansworth suddenly realized what it was that had been going wrong all this time, and she finally knew how the world could be made a good and happy place. This time it was right, it would work, and no one would have to get nailed to anything.

– Douglas Adams, The Hitch-Hiker’s Guide to the Galaxy

(Immediately after she realized it, the Earth gets destroyed.)

I’ve re-read it many times, along with re-listening to the radio series, the LPs, re-watching the TV series, I can even appreciate the feature film, despite it being the least of the versions. I dearly love Douglas Adams.

The only thing I haven’t done in many, many years is play the INFOCOM game. Too devious.

let’s maybe not push the propagandic idea that humans are inherently bad, humans are in fact inherently extremely friendly (to a fault) and the idea that the opposite is true is part of what’s needed to restrain our inherent need to help others.

Any time a group of humans is placed in a difficult position they start working together, there’s that famous example of a group of kids accidentally ending up basically recreating Lord of the flies except they just got along and eventually had pretty comfortable lives, because as it turns out working together makes things way easier!

Humans mostly help each other. Governments do not like challenges to their authority. Jesus was killed because of the challenge he represented to the Pharisees. Ultimately Rome killed him, but at the demand of the Pharisees and an unruly mob that had been whipped into a frenzy.

They killed him because all he did was preach the apocalypse and the end times to a bunch of poors that began upsetting the power dynamic.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=z8j3HvmgpYc

A place to share screenshots of Microblog posts, whether from Mastodon, tumblr, ~~Twitter~~ X, KBin, Threads or elsewhere.

Created as an evolution of White People Twitter and other tweet-capture subreddits.

Rules:

Please put at least one word relevant to the post in the post title.
Be nice.
No advertising, brand promotion or guerilla marketing.
Posters are encouraged to link to the toot or tweet etc in the description of posts.

Related communities:

It's all correct.(lemmy.world)

Microblog Memes

!microblogmemes@lemmy.world

Community stats

Community moderators