Lemdro.id

2 points

7 months ago

? I am confuse

States’ rights in this particular case led to marijuana legalization a bunch of places which was pretty far from what the Republicans wanted

And a bunch of Democrats have been fighting for full federal legalization for a few years now. I’m aware there’s a mythology that it’s every Democrat’s fault that 99% of Republicans voted in lock-step against it, which meant that little slivers of Democratic opposition were able to defeat it, but I’m not convinced by that logic

I’m aware that some Republicans use “states’ rights” as a fig leaf for their awful policies but how on Earth are you trying to apply it in that way to this particular issue

report

[ - ]

Ensign_Crab@lemmy.world

-1 points

7 months ago

? I am confuse

That’s because you didn’t read the single sentence I wrote.

States’ rights in this particular case led to marijuana legalization a bunch of places which was pretty far from what the Republicans wanted

I said nationwide. You responded with state level policy.

And a bunch of Democrats have been fighting for full federal legalization for a few years now.

Sure they have.

I’m aware that some Republicans use “states’ rights” as a fig leaf for their awful policies but how on Earth are you trying to apply it in that way to this particular issue

Because Democrats are content to let Republicans curtail rights for good people in red states, as long as they don’t have to worry in blue states.

report

[ - ]

2 points

7 months ago

Because Democrats are content to let Republicans curtail rights for good people in red states, as long as they don’t have to worry in blue states.

Yes, I’m aware of the narrative. I’m saying it doesn’t match reality (in this case – as a general statement about the Democrats of the Nancy Pelosi and Hillary Clinton brand, I fully agree with it + how it’s responsible for a lot of the lack of support for Democrats from the people who’ve been getting screwed).

I don’t really know how to lay out my evidence for my statement other than what I’ve already done… if you’re just planning on repeating the narrative back at me, IDK what to tell you.

report

[ - ]

Ensign_Crab@lemmy.world

-1 points

7 months ago

I don’t really know how to lay out my evidence for my statement other than what I’ve already done…

All you did was divert from national policy to state policy and say that Democrats are totally working on it on the national level without anything to back it up.

“We’ll look into it” isn’t doing shit.

report

[ - ]

1 point

7 months ago

Dude, why is everything a big fuckin argument with you. Here’s what I said:

what Biden could possibly have done aside from pardoning all federal convictions for possession, requesting the DEA to reschedule marijuana, and introducing a bill for full federal legalization

I actually learned since then that it’s a little more complex – it actually seems like maybe Biden was opposed to the full legalization bill that Schumer was pushing, and there was definitely some level of Democratic opposition in the senate. So maybe that piece of the criticism is legit, IDK, but OP never brought that stuff up to me when I asked what Biden should do.

That’s my opinion on the federal level. There are little breadcrumbs of things in there like “the full legalization bill that Schumer was pushing” that you can look up if you want to learn more about the facts behind it. You can form your own opinions, and I’m fine with that.

If you’re not interested in learning, and just interested in us shouting “YES IT IS” “NO IT ISN’T” “YES IT IS” at each other, I’ll pass.

(Actually - if you want to learn about the different legalization / decriminalization bills, and what the differences between them were / how they each fared and which ones if any Biden actually supported / things like that, and then tell me, then that’d be great, because I started reading but it was complex and I didn’t completely sort it out. But if it’s all going to be colored by this axiom you seem to operate under that everything Biden does is automatically a betrayal and there’s no need to learn anything more then I am not interested.)

report

[ - ]

Ensign_Crab@lemmy.world

0 points

7 months ago

I think what my attitude boils down to is that the Democratic Party has fundamentally earned my distrust, and that has only worsened since Biden took office.

After Biden didn’t fire the parliamentarian in order to get the minimum wage hike passed, I cannot trust that his hands are tied when his supporters say they are. As far as I’m concerned, Democrats tie their own hands. When it’s something that centrist Democrats want to do, his hands are utterly free.

You are taking Democrats at their word when they say they are powerless. I don’t do that.

report

[ - ]

1 point

7 months ago

Why, what happened with the minimum wage hike? Why do you say that firing the parliamentarian would have led to it passing?

You are taking Democrats at their word when they say they are powerless. I don’t do that.

Did you miss the part up above where I specifically said that I agree with your assessment, as applied to most of the Democrats (the Nancy Pelosi brand)?

report