You are viewing a single thread.
View all comments View context
21 points

I’ve heard of them. I’ve never heard of you. Your experience is insufficient data to be making this grandiose of a statement.

permalink
report
parent
reply
6 points

I’ve heard of them. I’ve never heard of you.

Not exactly a good thing… One of the problems with making a lot of noise is drowning out the voices of others on the same side.

Political capital is a thing, utilizing it in a protest that doesn’t really accomplish anything but turning public sentiment against your cause is kinda a dumb way to spend it.

permalink
report
parent
reply
9 points

You say they’re spending political capital. I say they’re building political capital. They’re creating a fuss. They’re creating noise, which can then be turned into action. What are you doing?

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

I say they’re building political capital. They’re creating a fuss.

The people who think of this as a net positive are already supportive of climate change initiatives. So who exactly are they building political capital with?

They’re creating noise, which can then be turned into action.

How? In what situation is there a problem that is more easily solved when people “make a fuss”?

What are you doing?

Not turning potential allies into enemies?

What are you doing?

permalink
report
parent
reply
8 points
*

I advocate for the cause I protest, not myself. How many people do you think will be compelled to care or learn more about climate change after this protest? How many people’s plans to see Stonehenge were ruined, leading to resentment of the cause?

Activism isn’t like Trump’s campaign. Bad press is in fact, bad press.

permalink
report
parent
reply
17 points

They have compelled more discussion in this single thread than you have with your whole life. Your moral grandstanding is nice. Effective tactics are nicer.

permalink
report
parent
reply
7 points

Discussion of what? Awareness of what? How do you see debating the method as success in discussion or awareness of a problem? If it were successful, we’d be sharing talking points, research materials, compelling speeches, etc.

This was an egotistical attempt to get noticed. It worked as intended.

permalink
report
parent
reply