Comment by PugJesus@lemmy.world on The conspirators who assassinated Abraham Lincoln being prepared for execution, Washington DC, USA, 1865

Not the death penalty’s biggest fan, but I’ll admit to a little bit of nostalgia on that particular point.

It gets tricky there doesn’t it?

I am against the death penalty.

This person commited treason against a just government.

I agree with your reply, it still leaves me conflicted though.

The way I see it, treason DESERVES the death penalty, but it shouldn’t ever be levied unless there is no other choice (ie a strong possibility of them being sprung, pardoned, or otherwise escape a life sentence by help of their fellow traitors).

Sometimes you don’t give people what they deserve because of what it does to you, not because of what it does to them.

The death penalty (which I abhor) ideally would only be used for those who are too dangerous to be kept alive.

I think Napoleon’s return is the best example of the consequences of not executing someone. He escaped from Elba and the wars started right back up, resulting in hundreds of thousands of military and civilian deaths in less than 4 months, only for him to be exiled again. If they’d executed him instead of sending him to Elba, the “hundred days” and the Waterloo campaign would never have happened.

Yeah, I think with dictators, cartel heads, and similarly “well connected” murderous figureheads the death penalty makes more sense. The line gets fuzzier when you get down to the level of like a cult leader - someone who maybe has connections but their power is probably insufficient to make escape likely.

your right, but also, you’re right.

hear me out: napoleon couldn’t help it. but he certainly didn’t do it alone.

the fucks waiting for him to escape, the fucks who furnished him with an army and weapons etc., - those are the fucks who should hang.

enabling sedition should be right up there with sedition, especially when it’s for personal profit.

Yes, but sometimes there’s an iconic leader that a movement centers around, and while the machine they drive is made up of millions of others, that personality is key.

It’s why Trump is so scary. Yeah, the GOP has been evil for decades. But the fascist shift of the past 9 years wasn’t something they expected. The GOP lost control of their own party with Trump, and now they’re as terrified of him as anyone, but unable to stop him. It’s become a personality cult that is no longer connected with political stances.

Liz Cheney was a textbook examen of a far-right establishment Republican, and she was driven out of office and is now in legitimate danger of assassination by the Trump crowd despite holding the same political positions. All because she didn’t bend the knee to Trump himself.

The GOP is also terrified at what comes after Trump. He’s nearly 80 and is the entirety of their platform now.

Yeah, the GOP has been evil for decades. But the fascist shift of the past 9 years wasn’t something they expected.

kinda disagree with where you take this line of thought - they’ve certainly been evil for decades, at least since the southern strategy - fosho - but the fascist shift is something they’ve been building for a decade+ since they realized demographics were not going to keep white people a numerical majority.

So they began a long campaign of gerrymandering (too many examples to begin to describe), disenfranchisement (tens of thousands of black votes discarded in florida that would have elected Gore) and political horror (Willie Horton et al) - and now they’re going to see it through with proj 2025.

I think this has been a longterm goal of the right for decades as they see no solution to being a minority except for minority rule.

With Napoleon specifically, they didn’t want to set a precedent that leaders of defeated countries should be executed.

With Napoleon specifically, they didn’t want to set a precedent that ~~leaders of defeated countries~~ monarchs should be executed.

ftfy

Well said!

(I’d modify “deserves” somehow but agree killing should be reserved for when there is some imminent risk.)

Well, the next question would be, “what’s the alternative?” Is lifelong incarceration better?

That’s the conflicted part. My brain said ’ what do you do?’ Kill them? Incarcerate for life? Neither are good options to me, I would hope for rehabilitation. At the same time I know that is not realistic in some cases.

There is this case in Japan currently. https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/jul/07/japan-death-row-iwao-hakamada-murder-retrial-verdict

At the time of this photo, I don’t know if an alternative would have been remotely feasible. It’s impossible to place judgement on historical actions with a modern moral lens. The idea of letting treasonous individuals live would have been untenable.

But as other posters have shown here in response to my comment, lifelong incarceration does seem to be the better option even if you’re looking at it purely from a policy and cost perspective. And rehabilitate is only possible if they’re not dead.

Good point! I think my biggest issue with this particular death penalty conviction was that it was through a military tribunal instead of civilian criminal court, and the defendants had inadequate legal representation. Even by the standards of the time period it was unjust.

Yes, lifelong incarceration is better. I’m sure there are cases where incarceration is less humane, but I’d argue that’s an issue with how we do incarceration and the death penalty isn’t the solution. Incarceration is certainly better for the moral and psychological well-being of the people carrying out the sentence. It’s better financially. It leaves open the possibility of correcting erroneous convictions. It leaves open the possibility of change, learning, redemption, and healing.

how is it better financially to keep someone incarcerated?

Now that has me feeling more conflicted.

`If you would like to become a mod in this community, kindly PM the mod.`

Relive the Past in Jaw-Dropping Detail!

HistoryPorn is for photographs (or, if it can be found, film) of the past, recent or distant! Give us a little snapshot of history!

Rules

Be respectful and inclusive.
No harassment, hate speech, or trolling.
Engage in constructive discussions.
Share relevant content.
Follow guidelines and moderators’ instructions.
Use appropriate language and tone.
Report violations.
Foster a continuous learning environment.
No genocide or atrocity denialism.

Pictures of old artifacts and museum pieces should go to History Artifacts

Illustrations and paintings should go to History Drawings

Related Communities:

Military Porn

Forgotten Weapons

The conspirators who assassinated Abraham Lincoln being prepared for execution, Washington DC, USA, 1865(lemmy.world)

HistoryPorn

!historyporn@lemmy.world

`If you would like to become a mod in this community, kindly PM the mod.`

Community stats

Community moderators