My top 5:
- Alien
- The Shining
- The Thing
- Evil Dead 2
- Hereditary
I don’t like horror movies but Shawn of the Dead is brilliant.
Movies that actually left me feeling unnerved:
The Witch
Bone Tomahawk
The Babadook
XTRO
The Hills Have Eyes (1977)
Top “fun” or interesting but not haunting horror movies:
Alien
The Thing
Friday The 13th Part 6
Evil Dead 2
House (1985)
(A lot of runner ups in the fun category, including basically all of the Jeffery Combs catalog, but I’m not even sure those can be considered “horror” instead of comedy with horror trappings. Similar to Dead Heat and the like.)
- The Thing
- Alien
- Braindead / Dead Alive
- Possession (1981)
- The Wolf House
This was so hard to narrow down
- Nosferatu (1922)
- Cat People (1942)
- Alien (1979)
- Under The Skin (2014)
- It Follows (2014)
The Wicker Man is at the very top for me, I never seek out horror films as any sort of fan of the genre, and this one transcends it.
So does Evil Dead 2. As well as The Shining.
So that’s three. Alien also belongs up there. Four down, one to go…
I’ll round it out with The Exorcist. And you know why that film was so shocking for the time? Because it wasn’t filmed as a horror film, but as a family drama. That dry context is what made it feel so immediate for seventies audiences, and it’s still effective today, as it’s not a conceit nor gimmick, it’s an artistic statement of intent.