I feel like as this goes on, this list just devolves into random Star Trek species.
I mean, the whole point of the Antedians and Breen is they’re total meme species.
I personally feel like one of the ACTUAL worst species in the franchise is LD’s Dooplers. While overall, the eponymous episode is great, probably one of the series bests, the Dooplers felt out of place. Usually, Lower Decks has a standard of doing things that are both ridiculous and plausible by Star Trek logic - in other words, the cartoon dial is usually set at 6 or 7 (unless it’s a hallucination), but I feel like the Dooplers were a jarring turn to a 10.
I never really thought about it, but you’re right, the Dooplers are too over the top and only make sense in a cartoon context.
The Pandronians from TAS and LD (the species that effectively have three independent parts) also make no sense outside of a cartoon.
I feel like the Pandronians aren’t as severe - maybe an 8. You could explain the floating in part as a naturally occurring anti-gravity system (which does canonically exist artificially).
I might be biased, though, in kn my Star Trek Adventures campaign, I have a Pandronian as my chief medical officer.
Yeah, at least they don’t violate conservation of matter like the Dooplers appear to.
On the contrary, Lower Decks made the Pakleds more than a one episode farce.
“Well, the Pakleds murdered the entire crew of the Solvang because everyone assumed they were a joke.” - Captain Freeman
I’m glad someone said this before I had to, thanks to Lower Decks pakleds are now easily the best C-tier star trek species.
Even before lower decks, “We look for things that make us go” is just an excellent meme.
Edit: Oh, this person is a first contact hater. While I don’t disagree with eveyr one of their opinions, they can now be safely ignored as a general rule ;)
Having grown up with TNG as my intro to Trek, this First Contact besmirchment will not stand!
TBF it’s only hated in implication but that’s too much for me.
Not only that in the same section he goes on to say that Frakes could have taken notes from TMP on how to set up Insurrection which is just… the weirdest take, since IMO those movies suffer from almost the exact same problems that come from making a pretty mid episode into a feature film.
Disclaimer: My article posts do not necessarily reflect my views
I like all the trek movies up until the Kelvin timeline movies lmao
Any trek movie/episode that features self-destruct to completion and/or ramming a ship into another as last ditch effort is automatically S-tier in my book lolol
Throughout several episodes in the first two seasons of Enterprise, the Suliban draw Captain Archer into the Temporal Cold War. That sounds cool, but the execution of the Suilban falls flat, starting with their design. They look like they’re covered in cheap green foam, giving them an unsettling texture that reads cheaper than even the aliens of the original series.
Look how they massacred my boy
At least the Suliban villain, Silik, was pretty cool. Sometimes an enemy, sometimes a friend, always throwing shade 👌
D tier:
But the music is good.
Come on, listing terrible aliens and the Ligonians aren’t at the top of the list?
