111 points

I was and continue to be shocked that there are conservative Star Trek fans. I just can’t wrap my head around how they justify it. It’s very clearly painting socialism and left leaning ideas as the universally correct ideals which will lead us to a utopia.

permalink
report
reply
31 points
*

The show is also about a space navy that has near total autonomy on the frontier, securing the interests of the Federation while inducting new worlds into its ranks, with our heroes being the Good Guys who are high ranking officers in the military who give orders and investigate conspiracies and hold life and death in their hands as they fly around their heavily-armed “totally not a warship” exploration vessels.

It’s very Space America, and at times almost libertarian in its politics and non-interference. It’s not even explicitly socialist, all we know is that they don’t use money, except when they do. The writing is sort of fuzzy on the matter, which results (regardless of the intention) in an economy that doesn’t actually seem that different to our modern day in practice. There’s no money, but people still own businesses and talk about buying stuff, which allows for the economic system to fade into a sort of forgettable background space.

Besides, Star Trek isn’t necessarily about a socialist future. It’s about a post-scarcity future. I think that’s a key difference. I’ve spoken to many conservative fans who say that they believe that capitalism is the only way that we can achieve a post-scarcity future, i.e. invent replicators. Because Trek isn’t about a worker’s revolution, it’s about the slow progression of technology, followed by a nuclear war, and then at some point they just sort of got rid of money because it was obsolete. All we even know about it is from one-off lines.

There’s a bunch of info on the economy of the Federation in this article on Ex Astris Scientia.

It makes me think of the Culture series, another sci-fi universe I’m fond of. It’s even more leftist-coded than Star Trek, yet somehow Elon Musk is a fan of it and names his rockets after ships from the books. Apparently Jeff Bezos is a fan too. Ugh. And as a result, a lot of people’s first introductions to the series is through these awful people, since it’s a lot more niche than Trek.

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

all we know is that they don’t use money, except when they do. The writing is sort of fuzzy on the matter, which results (regardless of the intention) in an economy that doesn’t actually seem that different to our modern day in practice

At most they use credits, which at least according to this guy, are at most a peripheral, 3rd party currency, or at least a currency the federation uses for external trade, and that’s what makes most sense to me. Why would the average person care about federation credits when they’re only used on border systems at most, and your home replicator can make you pretty much anything you’d ever want? To a person living in such a world, for all practical purposes there is no such thing as money in the federation.

There’s no money, but people still own businesses and talk about buying stuff, which allows for the economic system to fade into a sort of forgettable background space.

They never seem to talk about buying stuff unless it is out on the frontier, exchanging with foreign entities, etc. It also doesn’t seem like businesses in star trek (at least the above board, earthlike ones) aren’t anywhere near today’s businesses. To me, it seems that they are treated as family businesses, with limited “employee” count, and with each “customer” getting their service/food/item for free, within reasonable limits. It’s like going over to your family’s house for dinner. You don’t pay, you’re family and they will happily feed you (within reason). And it seems that businesses treat everyone like that.

There is no stock market, profit motive, costs of running a business. It’s all done out of the goodness of people’s hearts.

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points
*

I largely agree with your analysis here. My point was that the way the economy is portrayed is such that we don’t get to see much of how it actually works, meaning that a lot of our understanding is speculation based on a handful of lines.

Meanwhile, they’re still participating in the aesthetics of commerce within the Federation, and literal commerce beyond its borders. The idea that there’s a currency used for trade outside the Federation, but citizens get everything for free within it, is a popular interpretation but it’s never actually explicitly stated within the text outside vague mentions of a “Federation credit”. It’s personally my favorite interpretation, but I think everything’s vague and in the background enough that I can see how people can walk away with different interpretations. Just look at that Ex Astris Scientia article; I even disagree with where some of the evidence should fall on whether it’s pro- or contra- money.

The wildcard here is that we see Federation worlds that seem to still use money, namely the Bolians who are members of the Federation, but the Bank of Bolias is a major financial institution.

The interesting thing to me is that people often assert that replicators are the reason that money doesn’t exist in the Federation, but that’s simply not the case; it’s established in VOY that money “went the way of the dinosaur” in the late 22nd century, prior to the invention of the replicator over a century later. Neither replicators nor money existed in Kirk’s era. It seems that replicators are not essential to eliminating money in the Trek universe, although I’m sure they’re a boon to the standards of living.

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points

It’s said over and and over again how much better real food is compared to replicated food.

Things still have value, but it’s all “luxury”; that is, there’s no needs that are not being met.

I only say this to emphasise that replicators didn’t fix or replace everything.

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

The Culture is amazing, it’s an anarcho-socialist utopia that’s much more radical free than Star Trek’s society.

… I feel the same way as you about billionaires appropriating it.

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points

Some great points!

I like Steve Shives’s take on the issue

https://youtu.be/nNNWWdsEYGg?si=LVic9Z4wlQ0mLVZ5

permalink
report
parent
reply
17 points
*

They’re watching it for Crusher/Troi/Seven/Dax/Uhura. The technobabble confuses them and they think any solution they come up with in the show is just a byproduct of the fantasy premise. That or they identify with the Cardassians.

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

… “Multi-modal reflection sorting” should confuse you, on account of the fact it is nonsense.

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

Because classic trek - for all its reaching for the stars and left leanings - is still very much rooted in and reflects the US postwar mindset. We are the good guys! The best guys! We do no wrong! Which is a trough that right wingers like to feed at.

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

Maybe people like good writing and story telling and aren’t interested in “the message”?

permalink
report
parent
reply
80 points

They’re not big fans of ‘infinite diversity in infinite combinations’ either.

permalink
report
reply
4 points

Well, basically you have 3 types of people. Humans. Painted humans, and humans with prosthetic foreheads on their real heads.

Then you have SFX aka gods.

permalink
report
parent
reply
27 points

Thought the first rule was “Greed is eternal”?

permalink
report
reply
27 points

In a post scarcity society, greed becomes irrelevant.

permalink
report
parent
reply
49 points

This man doesn’t have the lobes for business.

permalink
report
parent
reply
17 points

If you can’t create artificial demand in a utopian society, what kind of Ferangi are you?

permalink
report
parent
reply
12 points

Post-scarcity societies are good for business. Rule of Acquisition #74.

permalink
report
parent
reply
4 points
*

Rule #74 is Knowledge equals profit. Are you reading some pirated copy of the rules?

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points

Define “post-scarcity”. You can’t replicate everything (without programmable matter, anyways…), and some raw materials are needed to build the replicators. And latinum is a rare commodity, though I don’t know why it’s so value beyond its scarcity. Greed will always be there as long as some things remain scarce yet required for a functioning society.

permalink
report
parent
reply
9 points

Latinum is only valuable outside of the Federation, where societies are not post-scarcity.

Now, before you argue that there are no material conditions demanding scarcity in (some of) them, I’ll add that artificial scarcity is scarcity nonetheless.

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

Latinum is valuable because it can’t be replicated.

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

Irrelevant, but it still exists.

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

When everyone has unlimited access to stuff, one person wanting more does not deprive others of anything so it does not matter if it exists.

IE: In a post scarcity society, greed becomes irrelevant.

permalink
report
parent
reply
17 points

Rule of Acquisition #1:
Once you have their money, you never give it back.

permalink
report
parent
reply
10 points

That’s it back in the wormhole with you

permalink
report
parent
reply
20 points
*

The socialist utopia that is Earth is a dystopic story for them. It’s like one of us reading Brave New World.

permalink
report
reply
19 points

Remember: Ferengi exists. In germany many call our libertarian party - FDP - Ferengi Party.

permalink
report
parent
reply
15 points

How can you be a libertarian on lemmy? There aren’t any children here

permalink
report
reply
5 points

But they aren’t pedophiles! They’re ephebophiles, which it totally matters to argue about the differences!

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point
*

No, but if you go by reading age, I can pretend pretty easily. Much more ethical source for my kicks than actual child predation.

permalink
report
parent
reply

Risa

!risa@startrek.website

Create post

Star Trek memes and shitposts

Come on’n get your jamaharon on! There are no real rules—just don’t break the weather control network.

Community stats

  • 819

    Monthly active users

  • 2.4K

    Posts

  • 29K

    Comments