cross-posted from: https://lemmy.world/post/13400226
I’ll admit I have zero insight and haven’t looked into this, but at first glance, I don’t understand why a desktop environment theme engine is unable to provide enough functionality for theme creators to do their thing without resorting to arbitrary command execution…
I trust KDE devs to address this quickly, but this is a pretty major oversight IMO…
“Global Themes” in Plasma do more than just styling
To developers it’s not a surprise that third party plugins can do this sort of thing. It’s as intended. A global theme can ship custom lockscreens, custom applets, custom settings and all of these can run arbitrary bundled code. You can’t constrain this without limiting functionality.
https://blog.davidedmundson.co.uk/blog/kde-store-content/
Naturally this is not what an end user expects when browsing for themes, and the warnings don’t make up for the risks.
I hope devs can find a better way to ship this rich functionality, or at least introduce an automated “canary-release” process to the KDE Store that takes down themes that misbehave.
This sounds very amateurish from Plasmas part as allowing themes to run bash scripts sounds like a very bad idea no matter how you look at it.
Themes should probably have something like their own domain specific language (DSL) that can be fed to the “theme engine”(?) which will make the requested changes. If additional functionality is needed it should be provided through separate modules/plugins or something.
My thoughts were sandboxing, so run it in a container with only predefined hooks out. That way you know what parts of the system a theme is wanting to change or access (think flatpak).
I do like the use of subset languages to reduce attack surfaces (eBPF comes to mind as an example definitely not a solution to here those lol).
Original report, in English:
https://old.reddit.com/r/kde/comments/1bixmbx/do_not_install_global_themes_some_wipe_out_all/
It’s possible that this deletion was a shell script mistake rather than malice, but it really shouldn’t be allowed either way. It’s made even worse by the UI that encourages users to install themes that that could have been made by anyone, with practically no oversight, and with no warning that they can execute arbitrary code.
I like KDE for a lot of reasons, but I’m ashamed of them for this irresponsible blunder.
Let’s hope they respond by closing this hole and any others like it. If they have to break compatibility with existing themes, now seems like a good time for it, since Plasma 6 was only just released.
Uk this prolly is an unpopular opinion, but KDE just isn’t as stable as it should be. When I used KDE (even when my friend used it) something or the other ALWAYS broke. Like just like that! The wifi icon bar or whatever disappeared. Why? Cuz it wanted to… Uggh it just feels like using alpha software, uk…
If Lemmy has taught me anything this is a Linux user’s dream because now they can install Linux on the machine.
NixOS users be like : meh, just rolling back
I keep seeing comments about NixOS. As a relative newby just messing around for themselves, is there anything stopping me from/I should know about taking the plunge?
I’ve only dipped my toe in Ubuntu.
As someone who’s using it daily:
It’s pretty cool. But it’s not a “best” solution. It, like anything, has upsides and downsides.
So let me quickly summarize NixOS for you:
you will have to learn new how to configure your system. You can’t go into your Settings App anymore (well, you still can, but then you could just stay on Ubuntu, that’s the whole Point of NixOS) but instead you’ll have a file in /etc/nixos/configuration.nix everything System goes into that Config File. Then you can also use home-manager to customize your user. i.e. you want to use a special ssh setting. Home-Manager is (in my opinion) only useful if you have multiple Computers and sync your Config Files between them (in my case via Git) as any change made on one Computer will be synced to the other.
so you have a lot more effort upfront. You have to relearn how to do stuff and you have to use a complicated File instead of a simple GUI.
BUT:
Once you did that effort, it is done. forever. You can just copy that Config file anywhere and you’re back on the exactly same system. Have two Computers and want to sync them? NixOS is the absolute best Option for that imo.
Spinning up a lot of Servers/VMs that you want to be pre-configured and ready for use? NixOS. Servers you always want the same way? NixOS. you can also already declare public keys you use for SSH Authentications.
so, you see, NixOS isn’t for everyone. It certainly is for me, but if you only ever use one Computer and prefer GUIs, stay away.
How is this any different than skeletons and using up ansible, salt or chef? Also hear a lot about Nix but don’t see the OS of NixOS
I keep wanting to dabble with nixOS as it almost seems like the docker compose of OS’s
But every now and then someone comments and acts like it’s really hard or something.
I so scared
If you can wrap your head around docker compose, you can handle nix.
That is to say, I’d sounds like you aren’t afraid of tinkering and looking at other people’s solutions until you get your setup right. That’s what NixOS is all about.
Solve that problem once, you’ve solved it forever. You don’t need to remember how you did it next time.
I daily drive it on 2 machines. Overall, it is super simple, if you know how to ready json or yml, you will understand the config file instantly. However, it is a unique OS, and works different than most other distros. As a result, any guide made for other Linux distros needs to be thrown out the window. It also doesn’t natively support most self executing packages like app image. All that said, it is fun and easy, just make sure when you look for support, you are looking for NixOS support.
Neon explained it better than I ever could! I hope their answer satisfies you
That whole feature needs a reboot, to be more like wallpaper engine.
I know this story is more-so about a trojan in a trusted place, and not general security, but I have an anecdote to share.
So, time to fess up here. I previously complained about Google trapping me in captcha-hell for enabling Ublock Origin.
I was wrong.
Turns out that I had visited a movie streaming site a while before to watch a season of some show, I forget which. Without any downloads or noticeable input on my part. My Linux box apparently got hacked/malware. All I did was click the occasional “I am a human” box on the website, and sit back with popcorn.
I found out when my ISP starting blocking IP addresses some time later. I checked my modem’s logs, and they showed some unexplained traffic to impossible “unassigned” IP addresses afterward. I didn’t notice for a while.
I was stupid. Even worse, my phone also started behaving badly after that. I think I watched the last few episodes in bed, so must have infected that too.
Don’t assume any system is automatically safe.
I really doubt anything escaped the browser, but websites can make nefarious connections, sure.
I hope so. It’s more likely something infected Firefox itself, and didn’t get into the OS. But when I checked the modem logs, it happened up to a couple of months after the fact. That’s worrying.
What’s even more worrying is that a couple of websites told me I had an IP address that didn’t match my home IP, but would provide the correct one if I refreshed the page a couple of times. So some kind of covert proxy or VPN type of thing was happening.
I ended up just wiping everything, to be safe. Still a bit paranoid though.
