Comment by Susaga@sh.itjust.works on

Some players are on MinMax overdrive

“Okay, so he gets to make a dexterity saving throw… That’s a 16, so he manages to sidestep you and you take the full damage. …No, he doesn’t have disadvantage, you made a huge shadow above him, he knew you were coming. Anyway, he continues his monologue, using your actions as an example of the foolishness of humanity.”

Obviously you don’t wildshape until you’re about to hit.

At terminal velocity? You’re gonna need to make a damn good check to time that right.

This isn’t a physics sim. This is a roleplaying game.

😉

To continue the quote, physics are what I allow them to be.

Going by the pure rules, you don’t have enough time to wildshape. You just splatter. I’m being kind by giving you the opportunity at all.

From this response and the others given here I think you should have better said “… this is MY roleplaying game”. I don’t think I would enjoy this attitude as a player.

That beeing said, you do yours. As long as you are having fun and you have players that enjoy your style of DMing, that’s all fine.

Not everybodies playstyle is compatible, and that is a good thing, because different people enjoy different things. I’m saying this because I want to make clear that I’m not trying to make a personal attack here.

No matter what the real world laws of physics are, the GM is the final arbiter of the rules. That’s not an ego thing. That’s just how it works. Everyone’s roleplaying game works the same, even if they have different rulings.

Now, let’s quickly picture this scene where the GM instead rolls 14. The BBEG is making his speech, then a shadow falls over him, he looks up, and gets crushed by a brontosaurus. He’s resiliant, having taken only half the fall damage, but he’s knocked prone and at a serious disadvantage as everyone rolls initiative.

Would anyone complain about the optional rule being used? Would anyone argue there should be no shadow because “the sun wouldn’t be there” or “I hadn’t transformed yet”? And if they decided to make that check to transform right before impact and succeeded, would they complain about the high DC due to the high speed?

I don’t think they would. I think they’re only complaining because the GM didn’t give them what they wanted. They don’t care about the game, they just care about getting their own way.

I agree. I am not compatible with that playstyle.

Brontosaurus is gargantuan, so you’d have to do a lot more than side step to get out of the way.

Call it what you want. By RAW, it’s a DC 15 Dexterity saving throw to avoid damage regardless of the size of the falling creature (beyond that if it’s tiny it does no damage at all). And that’s assuming you’re playing with the optional rules for creatures falling on other creatures causing damage.

I’ve seen that rule before. They didn’t carry it forward into the new rules, and for good reasons.

That rule comes from Tasha’s Cauldron of Everything which is compatible with the 2024 update so it’s still a valid RAW interpretation according to WOTC.

They carried forward all the other optional rules from Tasha’s, and not the that one. Clearly they didn’t like something about it.

They didn’t carry Artificers forward into the new PHB but they’re still a valid class. This rule not being in the newest books only means it didn’t need modification to fit with the new material not that it is no longer valid.

2024 is not a new version that completely replaces 2014, it’s an update where things stay the same unless they’re mentioned in the newer material, hence all the official adventure books being compatible with 2024.

Nope. The rules for falling on a creature don’t factor in size, except for if it knocks the target prone. The check is DC15.

Nope. Those rules are optional, and dumb, and now outdated.

First of all, if I’m the DM, you don’t get to tell me not to use a rule.

Second of all, there will not be a situation where I use the 2024 ruleset. The 2014 ruleset is still around, and still usable, and anyone calling it outdated is an idiot.

Third, this is the only official rule given for this situation. If we don’t use it, there is no rule for falling on someone and we resolve it however I like. And since you just tried to interrupt my monologue, I’m not inclined to be generous.

First of all, lol, we are probably not very compatible.

Secondly, they are literally outdated in an official capacity. I find they are improved for the most part, but have fun being so self-righteous about them.

Thirdly, no, they have improvised damage rules, which they specifically list large objects falling on players as examples. Improvised damage under Combat in chapter 8.

That rule was optional in an add-on book most tables won’t have, and didn’t get brought forward into the new core rules, unlike the other optional rules. There’s probably a good reason for that.

There’s a lot of things I can say about this. To summarise:

Just because WotC wants you to use a new product doesn’t mean the old product is outdated.
If WotC supports the Pinkertons, I don’t support them. But have fun letting your morals fall apart so you can consume product.
The Tasha’s rule expands on a rule from the DMG. If the rule were to be updated, it would be in the DMG, not the PHB.
Most tables don’t have the DMG either.
The new PHB doesn’t have most subclasses. The only reason stuff was omitted was because there wasn’t enough space or time to add them in.

All of that hardly matters, because you responded to a DM ruling by saying “nope”. No shit we’re incompatible. At the VERY least, I want my players to respect me.

you made a huge shadow above him, he knew you were coming.

Somehow I doubt it was established that the fight was at noon on the equator until that moment.

This isn’t a physics sim. This is a roleplaying game. Physics are what I allow them to be and it’s funnier for falling creatures to have a drop shadow.

If it’s large enough to impose disadvantage on a Dex save it’s large enough to cast a noticable enough shadow to grant advantage, therefore a flat roll.

The dex save has nothing to do with size (beyond needing to be Small or larger to deal any damage at all). I assume the Disadvantage was because they didn’t see you.

Humor, jokes, memes about TTRPGs

(s3.eu-central-2.wasabisys.com)

RPGMemes

!rpgmemes@ttrpg.network

Community stats

Community moderators